Posts

Opinion: No more SmartGrid cities

We are closing in on the end game. Xcel`s grand experiment of SmartGridCity is dying of its own financial and technical weight without ever having fulfilled many of the myriad of claims that Xcel made when they proposed it. The story is both depressing and illuminating. Around six years ago, the City of Boulder started to look at the idea of taking over from Xcel the business of supplying electric power within the city limits. The process is called “municipalization,” and is well defined in state law. (For example, Fort Collins, Colorado Springs, and Longmont are all munis.) Then, a few years into this study, in March of 2008, Xcel announced that Boulder was going to be its grand experiment in implementing a “smart grid.” The project was called SmartGridCity, and was supposed to provide customers with real time data on their electric use, allow Xcel to manage demand in order to make more efficient use of its generating facilities, support better integration of intermittent renewabl...

Opinion: Pricing services — lessons to be learned

As the Great Recession continues to impact local governments, we are seeing the effects of the various shortcuts that have been taken in the way we pay for services. When prices do not accurately reflect costs, serious budget problems can occur. Here are some examples. The City of Boulder is considering raising fees for recreation facilities and classes so as to more accurately reflect the real costs. Since these fees were previously subsidized, when sales taxes drop, shortfalls occur. Increasing fees seems a legitimate solution, but this economic necessity may not match the socially desirable outcome of having more people participate in these activities. The city is also looking at raising water rates. The rates, which are now pretty close to being cost-based, have actually induced conservation, which what was the intent. But the effect is that the utility is now running an operating deficit. Why? The reason is that most of the costs the utility incurs are fixed, like labor and ...

Opinion: Decision time for our energy future

On Tuesday night, the City Council will make a very important decision — given the goal of having a cleaner energy future with more stable prices, should Boulder investigate whether creating a municipal electric utility would be better than committing to a 20-year franchise with Xcel? The council may decide that Boulder should fully evaluate running our own electric distribution system, like Fort Collins, Colorado Springs, Longmont, Loveland, Estes Park, Lyons and many other Colorado cities do. This could provide more renewable energy, give us more local control, minimize the effect of escalating fossil fuel prices, and help both Boulder and the state toward a greener future. If the council decides to keep this option open, we will likely see a Five Year Utility Excise Tax on the ballot in November. This tax will replace the Xcel “franchise fee” for long enough that the city can fully research the alternatives. So it`s clear, the Xcel “franchise fee” is not paid by Xcel. It is a ...

Opinion: Energy slums or efficient housing?

Boulder is considering an ordinance that would require landlords to bring their rental units up to a reasonable standard of energy efficiency. The draft ordinance went to the Planning Board on Thursday, and will likely be considered by the City Council in May. But will the complaints by some landlords derail this important step in our efforts to address climate change while making rental housing more affordable? The need to use regulation to improve energy efficiency was recognized many years ago. The reason is simple: When the tenants pay the utilities, landlords do not have a direct incentive to improve energy efficiency. And tenants have little incentive to make improvements since they will not be there long enough for the energy savings to pay them back. This “split incentives” paradox is the main obstacle to upgrading rental housing, and is why regulation is the only effective approach. From my perspective, the complaints about the proposed regulations are overblown. Any bui...

Opinion: Xcel franchise — an opportunity not to be missed

Xcel’s franchise in Boulder expires in August, and the negotiations about putting a new franchise agreement on the ballot have not yielded much of anything new. But there is an opportunity here, both for Xcel and for the citizens and businesses of Boulder, to do something really innovative. For Xcel, the opportunity is to have a “laboratory” to learn how to deal with its customers when delivering a high percentage of renewable energy (RE) and managing it through its Smart Grid. For Boulderites, the opportunity is to receive “green electrons” for the majority of their electricity needs, and avoid, to some extent, the coming price inflation for fossil fuels. Fundamentally, the franchise is an agreement between the city and Xcel. Xcel gets Boulder as a guaranteed customer base for 20 years (with an opt-out at 10), and the city gets a 3 percent “franchise fee.” However Xcel is required to serve the city with or without a franchise. And Xcel doesn’t actually pay the $3-plus million “f...

Opinion: Three big steps toward a better energy future

The state legislature and the Governor`s Energy Office have been very active this session in moving forward their agenda for Colorado`s clean energy future. Three bills will make significant changes in our renewable energy goals, in the way citizens invest in solar generated electricity, and in metro area air quality. House Bill 10-1001, which Governor Ritter recently signed, raises the standard for renewable energy to 30 percent of retail electricity sales for 2020 and thereafter. This applies to Xcel Energy (about 65 percent of the state`s electricity, I am told) and Black Hills Energy (the other investor owned utility, about 10 percent). The 25 cooperative electric associations and larger municipal utilities must meet a 10 percent requirement. The bill is quite innovative: It rewards utilities for investing in renewables ahead of schedule; it reduces rebates as the cost of renewables drops; and solar owners will continue to pay to support more renewables even if they zero out th...

Opinion: Three big steps toward a better energy future

The state legislature and the Governor`s Energy Office have been very active this session in moving forward their agenda for Colorado`s clean energy future. Three bills will make significant changes in our renewable energy goals, in the way citizens invest in solar generated electricity, and in metro area air quality. House Bill 10-1001, which Governor Ritter recently signed, raises the standard for renewable energy to 30 percent of retail electricity sales for 2020 and thereafter. This applies to Xcel Energy (about 65 percent of the state`s electricity, I am told) and Black Hills Energy (the other investor owned utility, about 10 percent). The 25 cooperative electric associations and larger municipal utilities must meet a 10 percent requirement. The bill is quite innovative: It rewards utilities for investing in renewables ahead of schedule; it reduces rebates as the cost of renewables drops; and solar owners will continue to pay to support more renewables even if they zero out th...

Opinion: The billion dollar block of concrete

Xcel has been in the news lately. In the first week of March, Xcel refused to issue rebates for photovoltaic panels to the owners of a mobile home because it is not a “permanent structure.” Also, the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) approved Xcel`s application for a two-tiered rate structure for residential customers. And Xcel backed Gov. Bill Ritter`s plan to convert a number of coal plants to natural gas to improve metro air quality. Although not obvious, the fundamental issue that ties all these events together is one that all investor owned utilities (IOUs) must eventually face — how to make money while providing a cleaner environment. IOUs make money by owning assets on which they earn a rate of return. In Xcel`s latest rate case, in December the PUC approved a 10.5 percent return on invested capital and 6.21 percent payment on Xcel`s bonds. The insider joke is that utilities always want to build the next “billion dollar block of concrete” — not for the power, but because it ...

Opinion: Clarifying the rules of engagement

At the last City Council meeting, Seth Brigham, a citizen of Boulder and former council candidate, was arrested by the police after attempting to raise issues about the behavior of certain sitting council members. The city manager has provided a detailed account, as well as recommendations to minimize future problems. But the fundamental issues are still unresolved. What caused all the trouble was the council`s rule that “speakers engaging in personal attacks may be interrupted by the mayor.” The notion of “personal attacks” is vague, the word “may” allows arbitrary application, and the rule is inappropriate since many times citizens come before council specifically to criticize the actions of council members. What exactly is a citizen supposed to do if they disagree with the actions of a specific council member? If they criticize that person, they could be shut down. And what if the mayor “interrupts” one person but not another who says something very similar? Is there any recours...

Opinion: Unsustainable development and its effects

In Wednesday`s Daily Camera, we were all put on notice that the time it takes Boulder`s fire and emergency vehicles to respond is falling further and further behind both our own and national standards. Only the day before, many of us received e-mails from the city`s planning department inviting us to a workshop to discuss “sustainable growth and development” as part of the five-year update to the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan (BVCP). It doesn`t take a rocket scientist to see that past growth and resulting traffic increases have led to these slower emergency response times. And that given the amount of expected future growth (13,000 more residents and 60,000 more jobs to “reasonable buildout”) and the failure of the city to require that growth pay its own way, the notion of “sustainable growth and development” is an oxymoron. If this growth is pursued, our future is rather grim, with emergency response time being just one of many sacrifices. The response time problem is simple...